Meh. It's nice to have a low point soup in the house, but this one won't become a regular for me. As written it's just not great. I could see how it could be superb with lots of tweaking, but for me the beauty of these recipes is the simplicity. . . the fact that somebody else already figured out this points. There are so many other delicious 1-3 point soups, I won't waste my time on this one again.